Have you heard about the fair tax proposal? I was researching it in more depth lately, and I find the concept very interesting.
Basically, the whole idea is that the fair tax would replace all income and payroll tax and replace it with a federal sales tax of about 21 - 23 percent. When you first think about that, it sounds very scary. Tacking on 23% to the purchase of a new car would be horrible. It definitely has its pros and its cons, but I believe the pros may outweight the cons. Do I think we’ll ever get rid of income and payroll tax? Probably not, but I like that the idea is being thrown out there.
PROS
CONS
I encourage you all to check out the website and other materials to educate yourselves about the fair tax. It seems too easy when you start reading about, but then I started thinking that maybe it seeems too easy because I am so used to the current system. When I think about keeping all of my paycheck and eliminating the extremely complicated tax codes, I start thinking that this could be a great alternative to the current system. Many of you will have a lot of questions about this, and they answer many of them in the FAQ section. Once you start thinking about tax credits, deductions, IRAs, all you have to do is realize that you would not need that stuff, because your incom is NOT being taxed. My main reason for supporting the fair tax is that it taxes you for choosing to spend. I think that if people choose to live a lavish lifestyle, then they should pay heavily for it. It makes no sense that people at the poverty level get income and payroll taxes taken away from them. It is also a crime that the rich find ways to get out of paying taxes. So check it out, and let me know what you think. I’d like to hear your concerns.
3 Responses
Ralph
November 13th, 2006 at 3:04 am
1We sort of got half of this in Australia when we got the GST (goods & services tax) - similar to the UK VAT, or your state sales taxes.
Our rate got set at 10%, not 23%, so our income tax rates only got cut, not eliminated, the tax free threshold raised, and state stamp duties eliminated (eventually).
To get the legislation passed some items had to be exempt - eg. basic (unprocessed) food, water. Which meant it didn’t raise as much revenue as originaly intended.
In practice it seems to not be as progressive as most people had imagined - poor people tend to spend more of their income on taxable items (junk food, beer, cigarettes etc), while rich people spend a smaller percentage of their income on taxable items (wine, caviar, sports cars) and can save/invest more - which isn’t taxed until it eventually spent.
It was also supposed to help stamp out the “black” economy, but instead there has been a proliferation of “cash in hand” deals and bartering to avoid paying the GST.
Regards
http://enoughwealth.blogspot.com
Jacquelyn Hart-McCoy
November 13th, 2006 at 8:01 am
2Hey Erik,
I have thought about this a lot and I think it is probably a good idea. I have no idea why some people think it won’t help the poor. It would absolutely help the poor! They would have more money for things they need like food! (Which is not taxed.) and Housing! (also not taxed if you are a renter)
My one big concern is what you said about it slowing the economy. It may, or it may not but I do know my spending habits would remain the same. I buy things when I need them, and that’s that. Whether they are going to have a huge tax associated with them or not.
Thanks for bringing up this important topic.
Lessons Learned From Filing My Taxes Last Night at Money Crashers
February 5th, 2007 at 7:22 pm
3[...] Who’s with me on throwing out the entire 5,000 page volume of tax codes? What is the point? I say just tax us a set amount and throw out all of the loop holes that the rich take advantage of to get out of paying more taxes. See my post on the Fair Tax. What do you think about that? I like the idea of those that spend more get taxed more. Doesn’t it make sense? Rich people will get taxed more for their spending habits and poor people will be discouraged to spend more than they can afford, which in turn will help them from being poor! Maybe it’s only in a perfect world, but it seems like a reasonable alternative. Let me know if you hate or like the idea and why. [...]
Syndicate
Categories
Recent Entries
Recent Comments
Blogs We Like