Buy your next rental where rent is high against home prices. In 15 Midwest and Southern metros, a typical house rents for 7.4% to 11.2% of its value a year. Before you offer, check the city’s taxes, insurance, and vacancy, and what houses on that street actually rent for.
That share, a year’s rent divided by the price, is the gross yield, and it decides whether rent can cover a mortgage. In Zillow’s October 2026 figures, a typical house in the San Diego area rents for about 5% of its value a year, while one in the McAllen, Texas, area rents for 11.2%.
Now figure the mortgage payment on each, with 25% down and a 30-year loan at 7%. A typical McAllen-area house, worth $189,000, rents for about $1,760 a month, roughly $820 more than its $943 payment. A typical San Diego-area house, worth about $1 million, rents for about $4,130, about $860 short of its payment of nearly $5,000.
At those terms, the typical rent is higher than the mortgage payment in all 15 metros below, by about $270 a month in Little Rock up to about $820 in McAllen. That margin still has to pay the property taxes and insurance, plus the repairs, empty months, and management every landlord budgets for, so those costs decide whether a house makes money.
Since October 2023, typical rents have risen faster than typical home prices, so the yield on a typical U.S. house has climbed from 7.0% to 7.4%.
How the 15 metros were picked
Each price, rent, and yield here covers a whole metro area and uses Zillow’s typical single-family home value and rent, the middle of each market. Every metro on the list passed six tests:
- At least 600,000 residents in the Census Bureau’s 2025 estimates
- A gross yield of at least 7.4%, the typical U.S. yield
- More residents in 2025 than in 2020
- A typical single-family rent up at least 2% over the past year
- A location outside Florida and Louisiana, where hurricanes and insurers pulling out have driven up insurance costs
- A rental vacancy rate, the share of rentals sitting empty, not clearly above the national 7.6% this summer, allowing for the margin of error in the Census Bureau’s quarterly survey
Two big Texas metros fell short. San Antonio’s typical rent rose only 0.7% over the past year, and Census’s metro estimates put Dallas’s rental vacancy at 14.7% this summer, nearly twice the national rate.
The 15 metros, highest yield first
Here they are, from the highest yield down, with each metro’s typical house value and monthly rent.
- McAllen, Texas, has the highest yield of the 100 most populous U.S. metros, 11.2%, with a typical $189,000 house renting for $1,760 and its population up 5.8% since 2020.
- El Paso, Texas, yields 8.9% on a $234,000 house renting for $1,740, and Fort Bliss is the area’s single largest employer.
- Columbia, South Carolina, yields 8.6% on a $254,000 house renting for $1,820, and its population has grown 6.1% since 2020.
- Greensboro, North Carolina, yields 8.1% on a $264,000 house renting for $1,780, and Toyota says its new battery plant in nearby Liberty will create up to 5,100 jobs.
- Cincinnati yields 8.0% on a $315,000 house renting for $2,100, and Census’s quarterly estimates of its rental vacancy, 2.3% to 7.1% this year, stayed under the national rate.
- Augusta, Georgia, yields 7.9% on a $249,000 house renting for $1,640, and it’s home to Fort Gordon, where U.S. Army Cyber Command has its headquarters.
- Winston-Salem, North Carolina, yields 7.7% on a $279,000 house renting for $1,800, with its population up 5.4% since 2020 and its typical rent up 4.6% over the past year.
- Omaha, Nebraska, yields 7.7% on a $306,000 house renting for $1,970, and Census put its rental vacancy at 5.7% this summer, but Nebraska’s insurance costs the second most of any state.
- Grand Rapids, Michigan, yields 7.7% on a $354,000 house renting for $2,260, and its typical rent rose 4.2% over the past year.
- Indianapolis yields 7.7% on a $295,000 house renting for $1,880, but Census estimated its rental vacancy at 11.8% in each of the last two quarters, so budget for longer gaps between tenants.
- Oklahoma City yields 7.6% on a $244,000 house renting for $1,550, but its rental vacancy swung from 7.2% to 13.2% in Census’s estimates this year, and Oklahoma’s insurance runs about twice the national average.
- Wichita, Kansas, yields 7.6% on a $221,000 house renting for $1,400, and its typical rent rose 4.0% over the past year, though Kansas insurance also runs about twice the national average.
- Tulsa, Oklahoma, yields 7.5% on a $253,000 house renting for $1,590, and American Airlines employs nearly 5,000 people at its maintenance base there, the largest of its kind in the world.
- Minneapolis has the priciest typical house here, $395,000, but it rents for $2,460, a 7.5% yield. Within the metro, St. Paul caps yearly rent increases at 3% for rentals built before 2005.
- Little Rock, Arkansas, yields 7.4%, the lowest here and right at the typical U.S. yield, on a $228,000 house renting for $1,410, and its population has grown 4.0% since 2020.
Costs & rules that change the math
Property taxes come out of the rent every year, and several states on this list tax a rental more heavily than an owner’s home. Texas’s homestead exemptions, which shield part of a home’s value from tax, go only to an owner’s main home, so a rental in McAllen or El Paso is taxed on its full value, the state comptroller explains. Michigan charges a rental up to 18 mills, or $18 per $1,000 of taxable value, in school operating taxes that an owner’s home skips, according to its Treasury Department.
In South Carolina, a rental is assessed at 6% of its value, against 4% for an owner’s home, and pays school operating taxes the owner’s home skips, as Richland County, home to Columbia, explains. Indiana caps a rental’s yearly property tax at 2% of its assessed value, against 1% for an owner’s home, according to the state’s Department of Local Government Finance.
Insurance is the other big cost that varies by state. In Insurance.com’s 2026 study of quoted rates for a standard policy with $300,000 of coverage on the house, Nebraska, Oklahoma, and Kansas averaged more than $5,000 a year, about twice the $2,872 national average. Texas averaged $4,582. Get a quote on a landlord policy for the exact house before you offer.
Landlord law matters as well. Oregon, Washington, and California cap yearly rent increases statewide, while 36 states bar their cities from adopting rent control at all, according to the National Apartment Association, a landlords’ trade group.
Check the street, not just the metro
Every number above describes a whole metro, which mixes blocks where houses rent quickly with blocks where they sit empty. Before you offer, compare the rent the seller quotes with what similar houses nearby actually rent for. If you’re buying in another state, have a local agent or property manager pull those rents for you.
Start with the two or three metros whose typical prices fit your budget, and run one real listing in each through the mortgage test above, using its own tax bill and insurance quote.
Advertiser Disclosure: Many or all of the offers that appear on this site are from companies that compensate us, and some companies pay for sponsored content. That compensation may influence which products we cover and where and how they appear on a page, including the order in which they appear. We do not include every company or offer available in the marketplace.

