·

8 Places to Buy Shoes Online for Less – What a Return Costs at Each

A green running shoe beside its twin in a coral shoe box, the open lid holding a form headed RETURN
Just the Tip:

Discount sites, shoe chains’ online clearance sections, and brands’ own sale pages sell brand-name shoes for less, but the return terms decide whether a bad fit costs you. Before you order a size you haven’t worn, check the return window and the cost of a mailed return, since several sellers charge $8.50 to $9.99.

Subscribe for more tips like this in your inbox daily.

Shoes in the same size fit differently from one brand to the next, and even between models from one brand, so a pair ordered online is a guess until the box arrives.

Return terms split the eight sellers below into three groups. Three pay for a mailed return, though one does so only for members and another only in the lower 48 states. Three more take returns free in their stores but deduct $8.50 or $9.95 from a refund by mail, and the last two make you pay for every return you mail.

Here are the eight, from the friendliest return terms to the costliest:

  • Zappos shows the list price beside each sale price in its sale section. Returns are free through UPS within 60 days of delivery, down from the 365 days it once allowed.
  • Running Warehouse marks down last season’s running shoes in its clearance section. Returns are free for 90 days in the lower 48 states, with a prepaid label in the box, but worn shoes get only store credit or an exchange.
  • Nike keeps thousands of marked-down styles in its sale section. Members, who join free, can return most shoes within 60 days at no charge, even worn ones. Guests pay their own postage or return at most Nike stores.
  • Nordstrom Rack advertises savings of up to 70% on clothes and shoes. Online orders go back free at any Nordstrom or Nordstrom Rack store within 40 days, but a prepaid mail label takes $9.95 off the refund.
  • DSW sorts its clearance into price tiers under $30, $50, and $75. Returns run 60 days, free in its stores, and a mailed return costs $8.50 for any number of pairs. Swapping for another size is free by mail.
  • Famous Footwear runs Buy One, Get One 1/2 Off promotions, though returning one pair from a deal changes the refund. Store returns are free with no time limit, a mailed return costs $9.95, and exchanges happen only in stores.
  • 6pm is the discount site Zappos runs, with clearance shoes but without Zappos’s free returns. Returns run 30 days from purchase, you pay the postage, and there are no exchanges.
  • Joe’s New Balance Outlet is New Balance’s own outlet site for past styles, and it adds extra percent-off promotions to its markdowns. Returns run 45 days, and each pair sent back carries a $9.99 restocking fee.

The sellers with free mail returns make it cheap to order two sizes and keep one. Say you’re between a 10 and a 10.5 in a $140 running shoe from Running Warehouse. Order both, try them on a clean floor, keep the pair that fits, and send the other back with the prepaid label from the box. You pay $280 up front, $140 comes back once the refund posts, and the return costs nothing. From a seller that deducts $9.95 by mail, the same order at the same price leaves the pair you keep costing $149.95.

Keep any try-on indoors, since most of these sellers refund only unworn pairs. Zappos also wants its shoe box back without tape or postal labels, so pack it inside a shipping box.

Buy a size you’re unsure of from Zappos, Running Warehouse, or Nike as a member, or from DSW, Famous Footwear, or Nordstrom Rack when one of their stores is near you. Save 6pm and Joe’s New Balance Outlet for a model you already own in the right size.

Advertiser Disclosure: Many or all of the offers that appear on this site are from companies that compensate us, and some companies pay for sponsored content. That compensation may influence which products we cover and where and how they appear on a page, including the order in which they appear. We do not include every company or offer available in the marketplace.