Before you buy a vacation home to rent by the night, base your math on how often similar rentals nearby are booked over a full year, not a seller’s projection or the peak season. Make the offer only if local rules allow nightly rentals and the home profits after cleaning, platform fees, insurance, taxes, and any manager’s cut.
Unlike a long-term rental, a vacation rental earns only on the nights guests book, while its mortgage, property tax, and insurance come due either way.
Take a cabin that rents for $230 a night and costs $19,000 a year for its mortgage, property tax, insurance, utilities, and upkeep. Each booked night adds $40 for cleaning, supplies, and booking platform fees, and a manager takes 25% of revenue. At 70% occupancy, meaning guests book 70% of the year’s nights, the listing agent’s spreadsheet shows the cabin earning about $15,000 a year after costs. If it books 85% of its summer weekends but, like similar cabins nearby, only 35% of the year, it loses about $2,000 a year.
Don’t count on that loss to cut your tax bill. When guests stay seven days or fewer on average, the IRS’s passive-loss rules don’t count the home as a rental activity. Its losses, depreciation included, then lower the tax on your salary only if you materially participate, such as working on it over 100 hours a year and no fewer hours than anyone else, including a manager.
Before you make an offer, take four steps:
- Pull a year of occupancy and nightly rates for similar homes nearby from AirDNA, a paid data service that tracks active short-term rentals, and run your math month by month.
- Add up cleaning, supplies, the platform’s fee, utilities, furniture, repairs from heavy use, short-term rental insurance, and about a quarter of revenue for a full-service manager if you won’t run it yourself.
- Check local and homeowners association rules for permits, caps on rental nights, taxes on each stay, and bans on stays under 30 days, like the one New York City applies to whole homes.
- Plan on an investment-property mortgage, since Fannie Mae won’t treat a home that’s mainly a rental as a second home, and its eligibility matrix requires at least 15% down on a one-unit investment property.
Run the math at the market’s year-round occupancy and again 10 percentage points lower, and buy only a home that makes money at both.
See what similar listings in your market book and earn on AirDNA before you tour homes.
Advertiser Disclosure: Many or all of the offers that appear on this site are from companies that compensate us, and some companies pay for sponsored content. That compensation may influence which products we cover and where and how they appear on a page, including the order in which they appear. We do not include every company or offer available in the marketplace.

