·

Mitten Savings Review – A Top Rate Once You Keep $10,000

Mitten Savings logo
Money Crashers Rating
Good

Mitten Savings

  • Best for: Savers who will keep at least $10,000 in one account
  • What Sets It Apart: New accounts keep the rates in effect when they open for 180 days and still get any increase
  • APY: 4.41% on balances of $10,000 or more; 3.01% from $2,500 to $9,999.99; 0.05% from $100 to $2,499.99; each a variable rate on the whole balance
  • Features: NCUA insured through Community Choice Credit Union, counted with any deposits there; free electronic transfers with one linked bank account, out up to $50,000 a day and $250,000 a month; direct deposit accepted; apps for iOS and Android
  • Monthly Fee: $0
  • Minimum Deposit: $5, kept as your membership share; $100 to start earning
  • Cost: No transaction, transfer, or overdraft fees
  • Eligibility: U.S. citizens 18 and older who live, work, or worship in Michigan, or who join the Community Choice Foundation, whose donation Mitten pays; individual accounts only
  • Pros: Top-tier rate from $10,000; protection from rate cuts for 180 days; free transfers both ways; open nationwide
  • Cons: 3.01% under $10,000 and 0.05% under $2,500; one linked account and no debit card, checks, or wires; deposits can be held up to three business days; no joint accounts or phone help
Just the Tip:

Open Mitten Savings if you’ll keep $10,000 or more in it. At that balance, every dollar earns a 4.41% annual percentage yield (APY), and a new account’s rates can’t drop for its first 180 days. Under $10,000, the whole balance earns 3.01%, or 0.05% below $2,500, so put smaller savings in an account without balance tiers.

Subscribe for more tips like this in your inbox daily.

Mitten Savings is the online-only savings account of Community Choice Credit Union, a Michigan credit union that opened it to U.S. citizens nationwide in November 2026. Each tier’s rate applies to the whole balance, not just the dollars past its threshold, so a balance of $9,500 earns 3.01% on all of it.

Key Features

  • Variable APYs of 4.41% on $10,000 or more, 3.01% from $2,500, and 0.05% from $100
  • Rates and tiers held at their opening levels for a new account’s first 180 days, with any increase passed along
  • No monthly or transaction fees, a $5 minimum deposit, and $100 needed to start earning
  • Free electronic transfers to and from one linked bank account, with withdrawals up to $50,000 a day and $250,000 a month
  • Open to U.S. citizens 18 and older who live, work, or worship in Michigan, or who join the Community Choice Foundation, whose donation Mitten pays

Pros

  • One of the highest savings rates once your balance reaches $10,000
  • Protection from rate cuts for a new account’s first 180 days
  • Free transfers both ways, plus direct deposit from an employer
  • Open to U.S. citizens nationwide, with the membership donation paid for you

Cons

  • Under $10,000, every dollar earns 3.01%, and under $2,500 just 0.05%
  • Only one linked bank account, and no debit card, checks, bill pay, wires, or cash deposits
  • Deposits can be held up to three business days before you can move them out
  • No joint accounts
  • Help only by secure message or web form, with no phone line

Mitten Savings is worth opening for savers who will keep $10,000 or more in it, since every dollar then earns one of the top savings rates. Anyone keeping less earns more at Pibank Savings, which pays 4.40% on any balance against Mitten’s 3.01% or less, though Pibank sends withdrawals only by wire.

Learn more about Mitten Savings or see how it compares to the best high-yield savings accounts.

Mitten Savings logo

Mitten Savings

Money Crashers Rating
Good

Advertiser Disclosure: Many or all of the offers that appear on this site are from companies that compensate us, and some companies pay for sponsored content. That compensation may influence which products we cover and where and how they appear on a page, including the order in which they appear. We do not include every company or offer available in the marketplace.