Money you can’t afford to lose can still earn interest in high-yield savings, money market funds, CDs, Treasury bills, or I bonds. Pick the one you can cash out without a penalty by the month you’ll need the money, and skip any product sold as safe that pays far more than Treasury bills.
No investment pays a high return without the risk of a loss, and money set aside for a down payment, a tuition bill, or an emergency can’t take that risk.
Each option below is protected by FDIC insurance (NCUA insurance at a credit union), the U.S. government, or a fund’s short-term holdings. What separates them is how soon you can get your money back and what it costs to get it early, so the date you’ll need the money decides which one fits.
Here’s what protects each one, how fast you can reach the money, and the catch.
- High-yield savings accounts are FDIC-insured for at least $250,000 per person at each bank, and you can withdraw any day. The catch is a variable rate, which the bank can cut without notice.
- Money market funds hold cash and short-term debt, and you can sell shares whenever you need cash. The catch is that, unlike a bank’s money market account, a fund isn’t FDIC-insured and can lose value.
- Certificates of deposit (CDs) are FDIC-insured too and pay the rate you agree to for a set term, after which you get the money back. The catch is an early-withdrawal penalty that each bank sets, with no federal maximum.
- Treasury bills are backed by the U.S. government, mature in 4 to 52 weeks, and skip state income tax. To sell one early, you go through a bank, broker, or dealer, after 45 days if you bought it at TreasuryDirect.
- I bonds are government-backed and pay a rate tied to inflation, reset every six months, and now 5.51% for new bonds. You can’t cash one for 12 months, and cashing it before five years costs three months’ interest.
- Short-term bond funds hold bonds that mature within a few years, which makes them less sensitive to interest rates than long-term bond funds, and you can sell any time. Nothing insures them, and their price still falls when rates rise.
Use Treasury bills as the yardstick for any rate you’re offered. The Federal Reserve’s latest daily figures put the three-month Treasury yield, the annual rate the government pays to borrow for three months, at 4.32%. A product sold as low-risk that pays 7% or 8% does so because it carries a risk you can’t see. The SEC flags “high returns with little or no risk” as a sign of a Ponzi scheme. The one safe exception is the I bond, whose rate follows inflation and can top Treasury yields when inflation runs high.
Money you might need any day, like an emergency fund, belongs in high-yield savings or a money market fund, not a savings account earning the national average, which the FDIC puts at 0.39%. For an expense due within a year, buy a Treasury bill or a CD that matures before it. For a goal one to five years away, line up CDs to mature by the date, or roll Treasury bills over until then. Put only money you can leave alone for at least a year into I bonds, and use a short-term bond fund only for money that could ride out a small loss.
Before you buy a bond fund, look up its duration on the fund’s fact sheet. Duration measures how much a bond’s price is likely to move when rates change. By FINRA’s rule of thumb, a fund with a two-year duration loses about 2% for each percentage point that rates rise.
Say you’re saving for a down payment in two years. A CD ladder, a set of CDs that come due one after another before your closing date, has every dollar ready when you buy. So do Treasury bills you roll into new ones as each matures. Dividend stocks don’t, since a steady dividend won’t stop the share price from falling the month you need to sell. That’s the reason to keep money you’ll need within five years out of stocks.
Write down the month you’ll need the money, cross off every option you can’t cash out by then without a penalty, and put the money in whichever of the rest pays the most today.
Advertiser Disclosure: Many or all of the offers that appear on this site are from companies that compensate us, and some companies pay for sponsored content. That compensation may influence which products we cover and where and how they appear on a page, including the order in which they appear. We do not include every company or offer available in the marketplace.

