Debt that keeps growing comes from too little income or too much spending, and each needs a different fix. Add up one month of essentials, minimum payments included. If they come to more than your take-home pay, you need more income or lower fixed costs. If your pay covers them, the problem is spending.
The standard answer to growing debt is to cut back, and it works when spending outruns a solid income. It fails when rent, groceries, and a car payment already take the whole paycheck, because you can cancel every extra and still fall behind.
Picture two households that each take home $4,500 a month and spend $4,700. In the first, essentials alone cost $4,700, so not one dollar goes to extras and it still runs $200 short. In the second, essentials cost $3,200, and eating out and shopping take $1,500. The shortfall is the same $200, but only the second can budget its way out.
To see which household you match, pull last month’s bank and card statements and total your essentials: housing and utilities, groceries, transportation, insurance, and the minimum payment on every debt. Count a bill you pay once or twice a year at one-twelfth of its yearly cost. If the total is more than your take-home pay, you have an income problem. If your pay covers it and your debt still grows, you have a spending problem.
Trimming small purchases can’t fix an income problem, because the shortfall starts before you buy anything extra. Ask for a raise or find a better-paying job, add side income, or cut a large fixed cost by moving somewhere cheaper or trading your car for one with a smaller payment.
A spending problem needs automation. Schedule a transfer to savings and an extra payment toward your debt for payday, so both come out before you can spend the money. The second household could cut eating out and shopping from $1,500 to $1,000 a month. That $500 covers its $200 shortfall and leaves $300 to send out on payday.
Run this test before you choose a payoff plan. No plan can shrink a balance your budget adds to every month.
Subscribe and we'll send you 101 Essential Money Tips to get you started.
The 101 money moves that matter most, from the foundations to protecting what you’ve built.
Advertiser Disclosure: Many or all of the offers that appear on this site are from companies that compensate us, and some companies pay for sponsored content. That compensation may influence which products we cover and where and how they appear on a page, including the order in which they appear. We do not include every company or offer available in the marketplace.
