How to Have a Successful Garage Sale – Tips for Pricing Items

garage sale signFew things make me happier than turning my unwanted clutter into cash. There are several ways to do this, including selling on Craigslist, setting up auctions on eBay, and utilizing newspaper classifieds. However, I’ve found that a good old-fashioned garage sale often works best, especially when you have a lot of small things to sell.

Having a garage sale takes work and can be extremely frustrating if you don’t know what you’re doing. To avoid any headaches and to streamline the process, follow a plan from beginning to end. A well-planned garage sale often means a more successful one, which means more money in your pocket at the end of the day.

Planning Your Garage Sale

1. Pick a Date

The first step is to choose dates and times for your garage sale. Most people go with Friday and Saturday mornings, but you can add Thursday or Sunday to a multi-day sale if your schedule allows. You’ll get a larger crowd if you start early because people won’t have to interrupt their day to attend your sale, and it’s likely to be cooler out which is an important consideration especially in the heat of summer. I typically run my garage sales Friday and Saturday from 6 a.m. to noon.

Pro Tip: If possible, hold your garage sale when the weather is moderate. Skipping out on the sweltering August heat and waiting for the end of September will give you a better shot at having a successful sale. You’ll get the most customers in the late spring or early fall.

2. Gather Your Goods

Garage sales offer a great way to declutter and downsize your house. Grab a box and go through every room. Pick up anything you don’t want or haven’t used in months and toss it in. Don’t forget closets, attics, basements, and garages as these are usually treasure troves for garage sale finds. Don’t underestimate the value of what you find either; people will buy anything from old CDs to unwanted bottles of perfume. After all, the worst case scenario is that something doesn’t sell.

Pro Tip: Have any old power strips, cell phone chargers, or USB cables you’re not using? Throw them in a separate shoe box to sell at the garage sale. It doesn’t matter if you’re not sure what that charger even worked for; someone may buy it.

3. Check on Permits

Many cities now require that you have a permit to run a garage sale. Check with a clerk at your city or town hall to find out if you need one. Don’t try to run a garage sale without it or you may end up getting shut down and fined.

Pro Tip: Some cities allow you to apply for permits online. Check your town hall website and look under the “permits” or “civic responsibilities” section to see where you can apply.

house garage sale setup

Advertising Your Garage Sale

1. Create a Newspaper Ad

If you want to drive major traffic to your garage sale, fork up the money to pay for an ad in your local newspaper. But before you write your ad, find out how much space you get for the price you’re willing to pay. If you go over, you’ll end up paying per word, which can get very expensive fast. Keep your ad short and pointed, and list your biggest ticket items first. The most popular garage sale items include furniture, kids’ toys, and collectibles. Don’t forget to include your address as well as the dates and times your sale will run.

Pro Tip: Consider advertising in your local paper as well as the major daily newspaper in your area. Most local papers charge $15 or less for ad space, and every home in the area gets a free copy, which means more potential customers for you.

2. Advertise Online

There are dozens of websites where you can advertise your garage sale for free. Post an ad on as many as you want, but aim for at least three. For example, I use:

You’ll have more wiggle room in the text of your online ad since most websites give you a generous word count. Feel free to describe your items in detail, but avoid sounding like a marketing executive. Simply tell people what you have and when you’ll have it, and let their own imaginations work out how wonderful it is. Also, don’t post your ad too early. If you’re holding your garage sale on Friday, it should go up Wednesday night or Thursday afternoon.

It’s also a great idea to utilize free social media marketing sites to get the word out in your local area.

Pro Tip: Write your ad in a word processing program and simply copy and paste it to each listing website site. This will save you the hassle of retyping it over and over again.

3. Make Yard Sale Signs

Check the laws in your area before making garage sale signs as some places have banned them. A clerk at your local police station can tell what you can and can’t do. If you are allowed to make signs, I’ve found that brightly colored poster board and a Sharpie is all you really need. Make sure your sign says “Garage Sale” large enough for people to see as they drive by. Include your address or an arrow pointing towards your house.

Pro Tip: Wood paint stirrers make great posts for sticking garage sale signs in the ground. You can get the stirrers free from most home improvement stores.

garage sales newspaper

Prepping for the Sale

1. Get Supplies

Make sure you have everything you need at least a day before the garage sale starts. You’ll need chairs to sit on, a table or other flat surface to take payments and provide change, and plenty of areas to display your goods. Don’t waste money on renting or buying tables. You can find or make enough surfaces to suit your needs.

For example, I gather up all of the card tables and patio furniture I can find for placing breakable items on. For smaller, non-breakable items, I put a board over two milk crates. For clothes, you can use a garment rack or hang them on hangers off the top of your garage door.

Pro Tip: Keep tables with breakables off to the side of your sale or against a fence. Unattended kids love to run underneath tables, so the more centrally located they are, the higher risk you run of the table being knocked over.

2. Don’t Forget the Change

Odds are, you’ll have to make $19.95 in change for your first customer. Make sure you have fives, ones, and at least twenty dollars in quarters. You can get them from your bank, but you’ll have to go inside a branch to do it.

Pro Tip: Ask the bank for a reusable cash envelope. Many branches are happy to give you one. You can use the envelope to run extra money back into the house throughout the garage sale so you won’t have tons of cash lying around outside.

3. Sort Your Items

Sort before your price. It’s the easiest way to keep your garage sale organized and make it easy on potential buyers. Dedicate a room in your house to garage sale planning and divide all of your items by category, such as clothes, books, home goods, and kids’ toys.

Pro Tip: If you have a lot of clothes, divide them by men’s, women’s, and children’s. Most people are looking for something specific and will appreciate the organization.

4. Price Your Items

It’s best if you price your items individually rather than just group them into boxes with one price sign. As the garage sale progresses, people will get the boxes mixed up and you’ll have a hard time keeping it organized. To price items, I just use a roll of manila tape and a Sharpie, which is a lot cheaper than going out and buying fancy price tags.

Pro Tip: Don’t increase your prices on the assumption that everyone likes to haggle. While many people do enjoy a good verbal match, some will just walk away if they think items are priced too high.

5. Organize and Arrange Your Sale

Arrange your tables and put all the clothes on hangers the night before the garage sale. No matter what you tell yourself, you won’t have enough time to do it in the morning. I arrange everything the night before and store it in the garage for safekeeping. Map out where everything will be placed to make the morning setup as easy as possible and to keep it in a logical and organized fashion for customers.

Pro Tip: If you can’t put everything in the garage the night before, group similar items into laundry baskets and boxes. You will save time in the morning if you only have to pull items out of boxes that don’t require further separation.

garage sale people

Throwing Your Garage Sale

1. Get Ready

Give yourself at least an hour before the garage sale starts to set everything out and put up signs. Make sure you have your change in a safe place, and find a comfortable, shaded area to sit.

Pro Tip: If your garage sale is hard to spot from the street, place a yard sale sign in front of your house so people know where to stop.

2. Work the Crowd

In an ideal world, a garage sale would work like Target. People would come in, grab what they wanted, pay, and leave. Unfortunately, people see garage sales as a sort of interactive shopping experience. They’re going to ask questions, they’re going to haggle, and they’re going to pick up everything, especially if it’s breakable. You’ll do better if you don’t act pushy. Just stay seated, shout out a friendly hello when people walk up, and let the customers come to you.

Keep in mind that you don’t have to haggle right away. Don’t let your couch go for five dollars with the first customer. Odds are that someone else will come along willing to pay your asking price. Start haggling like crazy using effective negotiation strategies on the last day, or in the afternoons after the morning rush.

Pro Tip: Position your chair so that you can easily spot people walking up and make sure you greet everyone. Saying a quick hello makes shoppers more comfortable about standing in your driveway.

3. Deal with Leftovers

You’re going to have leftover stuff. You can just put it all on the curb with a free sign, but that won’t get you any more money. Instead, consider taking the leftovers to a Goodwill store and save on your taxes. Make an itemized list of everything you have with its original value. Once you drop it at a donation center, ask for a receipt. File this away to use for a tax deduction for charitable donations on your income taxes.

Pro Tip: If you have large items left over, like a couch or a TV set, consider selling them on Craigslist. Craigslist surfers love to buy big-ticket items and you’ll make more money than you would donating them and using the tax deduction.

Final Word

Garage sales are a lot of work, especially if you’re not used to holding them. You’ll probably spend several hours organizing and pricing items, writing ads, and getting your supplies. But after it’s over, you’ll hopefully have a wad of cash instead of piles of stuff you don’t want, which makes it all worthwhile.

Have you ever thrown a garage sale? What are some of the methods that have worked best for you?

  • Tracy

    Great article, love the negotiation strategies!

    • Angela Colley

      Thanks Tracy! People love to negotiate at a garage sale. I’m not very good at haggling and have let big ticket items go for way less than I should in the past. It is a way better strategy to just use reasonable prices from the start and say no if you have too.

  • Casey Slide

    This is a very helpful article! I love the tip about making sure you have change before you start your sale. I am throwing my first garage sale next month. Thanks for all the great advice!

    • Angela Colley

      Thanks Casey!

  • Reyesdorta

    I did retail work for several years and this is great advise. Had my first garage sale last year, it was great! looking forward to my second in September. I can appreciate the tip on allowing people to come and look around freely….. thx.

    • Angela Colley

      Thanks! Good luck on your next garage sale!

  • Wendy Hendricks

    At our garage sales, we use a carpenters apron (two large pockets in front) for carrying around the cash and change. They cost only a few dollars at a hardware store. You never have to worry about leaving your money unattended if you need to walk around and help a customer or do some rearranging.

    • Angela Colley

      That is a great idea Wendy. I’ll have to try that at my next garage sale. I feel like I’m always worried about the money box the whole time.

  • Laura

    Excellent ideas!

    • Angela Colley

      Thanks Laura!

  • Natalie

    I am only 12 and I’m going to run a yard sale because we are saving up to move to our dream house. Your tips are great thanks!

  • Natalie

    I am only 12 and I’m going to run a yard sale because we are saving up to move to our dream house. Your tips are great thanks!

  • Allbert

    Proper advertising and presenting all selling items in an organised manner are the two main things in yard sale that helps to get a successful one. Apart from this, pricing stuff properly is also another important thing to consider in yard sale field. Very useful tips.

  • Sarah

    One of the things that works great for me is having a men’s table. A lot of my garage sales have mostly women’s and kids’ items, so I have a table with only men’s items such as hardware and tools. Men are immersed in this stuff while the women do the ‘real shopping’!

  • Ann

    Hi Angela! I hope you are still watching this post. I love it!
    My question for your is the hours you mentioned friday and sat 6 am to noon. Did these times really work for you???
    Lots of garage sales I see are from 8-4 pm. what is the advantage to close early?
    thanks for your time.

    • Peg D.

      This is my 7th Annual “FINAL” yard sale Ha! They are a ton of work but I have something for EVERYONE! Even brand new, never opened items and my time limit is 8am to 2pm. If you say “later than 2, all the other yard sales will be visited first and the $ will be spent. The shorter the time, the better

      • Jen

        That’s such a shame. If everyone else is closing at noon, too, how many sales do you think people are going to be able to get to? Not to mention people with kids in sports leagues that hold their games all season long on Saturday morning. Can’t tell you how many times we got out of the football games and wanted to go to yard sales, but most were packed up. If you don’t want a part of the $100 I routinely set aside for yard sales, that’s fine. Someone who understands that life happens on Saturday mornings will be happy to take it. ;)

        • Stewart

          I enjoy having my later 10-to7 (yes I am an all day person) I like to hit up the people after work/school and weekends

  • Janey

    I understand not having garage sales in the heat of summer. We need to have one within a few weeks and is it the same for the cold weather? In Jax FL so need to wait for weather that is a little warmer since we are having a cold snap? What is the rule of thumb on cold weather?

  • jyladvik

    Don’t give your stuff away. When you do this, customers then expect other sellers to do the same. It hurts business for everyone who does garage sales.

  • Cruz Smith

    Super helpful tips. Just purged one of my closets and got rid of thousands of dollars in clothes, some with tags still on. Don’t want to “give away” $$$ so am having garage sale. Will donate whatever doesn’t sell to a woman’s shelter.

  • Will Of Truth

    This is a straight guide to having a yard sale right down to the early birds, they were there right when we opened the garage. I was laughing to myself all day long it was like you were there.

  • Holly Anderson

    Great tips! Thanks for sharing! Another idea: if you have multiple families it can be a huge pain to track what each person sold. There’s an app called TallySheet that allows you to ring up sales and track them right on your phone or tablet. Cuts out a lot of the hassle!